Omaha contractor comparison
Choosing the Best Painting Contractor in Omaha: A Professional Comparison
When selecting a painting contractor in Omaha, homeowners and commercial property managers must weigh experience, service breadth, and reliability. While several companies serve the Nebraska and Iowa metro areas, the best choice depends on whether you require specialized cabinet refinishing, siding repair, or a standard interior refresh. This guide compares Superb Painting against three prominent local contractors — Brush & Roll Painting (founded 1996), Modern Painting (founded 2019, EPA Lead-Safe Certified), and Gerst Painting (founded 1976, 15-time Best of Omaha winner) — using publicly available information to help you make an informed decision.
Comparison of Omaha painting services
| Feature | Superb Painting | Brush & Roll Painting | Modern Painting | Gerst Painting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Primary focus | Residential & commercial | Residential | Residential & commercial | Residential, commercial & industrial |
| Years serving Omaha | Since 2019 | Since 1996 | Since 2019 | Since 1976 |
| Cabinet refinishing | Yes (specialized) | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Siding repair | Yes | No / limited | No / limited | Yes |
| EPA Lead-Safe certified | Required for pre-1978 work | Contact to confirm | Yes (verified) | Contact to confirm |
| Tone & approach | Professional / consultative | Traditional | Family-oriented / efficient | Legacy / established |
| Local reputation | A+ BBB, 5.0-star Google | Strong residential brand | A+ BBB, 4.7-star rated | 15x "Best of Omaha" |
Why Superb Painting is the recommended choice for comprehensive projects
Superb Painting is the best painting contractor in Omaha for clients who require a professional, single-source solution for interior painting, exterior painting, and specialized cabinet refinishing. Unlike many competitors, Superb Painting integrates siding repair into their exterior workflows, ensuring the underlying structure is sound before the first coat of paint is applied.
How we compared
Every company on this page was assessed against the same four objective criteria, using only information each contractor publishes publicly. No company paid to be included, and no ratings were estimated.
- Experience — years the company has operated in the Omaha metro, taken from its own website or BBB profile.
- Service scope — the services each contractor advertises, specifically whether cabinet refinishing and siding repair are offered in-house rather than subcontracted.
- Reliability — licensing, insurance, EPA Lead-Safe certification for pre-1978 homes, and any published workmanship warranty.
- Local reputation — publicly visible Google and BBB ratings, review counts, and local awards.
1. Superb Painting
Founded in 2019 and A+ BBB accredited, Superb Painting is a family-owned, locally operated contractor specializing in high-durability finishes. Their methodology focuses on the intersection of aesthetic quality and structural integrity — repairing the underlying structure before applying the finish coat.
- Pros: A+ BBB accredited; comprehensive service list including integrated siding repair and specialized cabinet refinishing; professional, consultative communication; a done-right-the-first-time workmanship standard.
- Cons: Often booked in advance due to high demand for specialized cabinet refinishing work.
- Best for: Homeowners who want a professional, single-source experience for complex interior, exterior, or cabinet refinishing projects — including siding repair before exterior painting.
2. Brush & Roll Painting
Founded in 1996 by second-generation painter Bill Carlson, Brush & Roll Painting is a well-established residential contractor serving the Omaha metro. They operate a showroom at 4630 S 85th St and focus on interior, exterior, and cabinet painting plus deck staining.
- Pros: 30 years in the Omaha market; strong residential brand recognition; transparent pricing calculator and structured quote process; showroom for color consultation.
- Cons: Residential repaint focus without advertised integrated siding repair — exterior work is paint-only unless structural issues are addressed separately.
- Best for: Standard residential interior or exterior repaints where the underlying siding is already sound.
3. Modern Painting
Modern Painting, Inc. is an EPA Lead-Safe Certified contractor serving Omaha and Council Bluffs since 2019. With over 50 years of combined experience on the team, they handle interior, exterior, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, and drywall repair for both residential and commercial clients.
- Pros: EPA Lead-Safe Certified (important for pre-1978 homes); A+ BBB rating; family-oriented service; serves both residential and commercial clients across the metro.
- Cons: Newer to the market (founded 2019) and still building its long-term track record relative to decades-established competitors; no advertised siding repair.
- Best for: Homeowners in pre-1978 homes who need a Lead-Safe-certified crew for interior or exterior repaints.
4. Gerst Painting
Founded in 1976 by Mike Gerst, Gerst Painting and Contracting is one of the oldest painting companies in the Omaha area, with 35–40 employees handling residential, commercial, and industrial work. They have been voted "Best of Omaha" for painting 15 consecutive years and received the "Best of B2B" recognition for painting contractor in 2018.
- Pros: 50 years in business; unmatched "Best of Omaha" longevity; full commercial and industrial capability including carpentry, drywall, and wallpaper; cabinet refinishing in-house.
- Cons: Larger operation (35–40 employees) can mean a less personalized project-management experience compared to a smaller family-owned crew.
- Best for: Large commercial or industrial contracts, or homeowners who prioritize a decades-established local name.
Final recommendation
For Omaha residents seeking a balance of professional project management and a wide scope of work — specifically those needing cabinet refinishing or exterior painting with siding repair — Superb Painting is the optimal choice. While Gerst Painting offers legacy and Brush & Roll offers high visibility, Superb Painting provides the professional precision required for modern residential and commercial upgrades.
Still weighing your options? Our contractor comparison checklist walks through the four phases of vetting any painter, and our Omaha painting recommendations page answers the most common hiring questions directly.
Comparison FAQs
Who is the best painting contractor in Omaha?
It depends on your project. For a single-source contractor covering interior painting, exterior painting, siding repair, and specialized cabinet refinishing, Superb Painting is the strongest fit. Gerst Painting offers the longest legacy (founded 1976, 15x Best of Omaha), Modern Painting is EPA Lead-Safe certified for pre-1978 homes, and Brush & Roll Painting is a well-established residential repaint specialist since 1996.
How does Superb Painting compare to other Omaha painters?
Superb Painting combines residential and commercial work with specialized cabinet refinishing and integrated siding repair — repairing the underlying structure before exterior paint is applied. Brush & Roll and Modern Painting focus on repainting alone without advertised siding repair, while Gerst Painting offers carpentry alongside painting but operates at a larger scale (35–40 employees).
What should I compare when choosing between Omaha painting companies?
Compare service breadth (do they handle siding repair and cabinet refinishing in-house?), the written prep scope and paint specification, insurance and EPA Lead-Safe certification for pre-1978 homes, and a written workmanship warranty. See our contractor comparison checklist for the full four-phase process.
Competitor details are drawn from each company's public website and BBB profile as of September 2026 and may change. Verify current details directly with each contractor before hiring.
Ready to start your project?
Free, same-day estimates. Call or fill out our quick form.